'Truth In Sentecing' Act Does No Favours for Poor and Aboriginal Peoples

An internal report submitted to cabinet in 2009 singled out Aboriginal, poor, and illiterate peoples as potentially being profoundly negatively affected by the implementation of Bill C-25. The so-called Truth in Sentencing Act, which came into effect in February of 2010, changed the policy on credit given for time served prior to sentencing. The Bill mandates that judges can only award equal credit for time served in custody while awaiting trial at conviction. The only exception to this is in special circumstances when they submit written reasons in an attempt to have 1.5 pre-sentence time credited for an individual.

Canadian media have recently gained access to the July 2009 preliminary report conducted by Justice Canada through the Access to Information Act. The internal report cited that in 582 cases of people awaiting trial across Canada, those held in custody in Winnipeg and Whitehorse had to wait longer for their trial dates than in-custody accused in Vancouver and Toronto.

In my experience, in custody accused are waiting 3-6 months for a trial date in Vancouver. If they’re waiting longer in Winnipeg and Whitehorse, that’s a disgrace. All accused are presumed innocent, including those who are waiting for a trial.

It is never the well-heeled that are disadvantaged by this kind of legislation. The Tories are putting the publicity value of being “tough on crime” in front of the rights of individuals, again.